The Best Ice Cream Maker: A Comprehensive Buyers Guide

When you think about ice cream makers - the first thing that may come to your mind is summer! Looking for an ice maker? Read our comprehensive guide to buying an ice maker.

We love summer too! Summer is a great for grabbing those cold drinks, and relaxing by the pool. But ice cream is not just for summer - it’s for any time. There is never a wrong time to have an ice cream cone, an ice cream sundae or some other frozen treat. We love ice coffee, but ice cream is in a class all to itself.

The best way to make your own ice cream is by purchasing an ice cream maker. With the advancement in household appliances, we are now able to quickly and easily make ice cream within the comfort of our own home.

What are the best ice cream makers that are available on the market today? We have put together a comprehensive buyers guide that will guide you through the buying process. In order to make the right decision we have divided this list into three categories: Attachments, Frozen Bowls or a compressor unit.

#1. TOP ATTACHMENT ICE CREAM MAKERS: Attachments that you add to an appliance that you already own.

The KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment

If you have a KitchenAid, then this is an excellent choice for you. The KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker attachment produces two quarts of fantastic soft ice cream in as little as 20 minutes.

This KitchenAid attachment allows you to create some unbelievable frozen treats and because you already have a KitchenAid mixer, you don't have to store another small appliance on your countertop.

Click below and get the best price on Amazon.

#2. TOP FROZEN BOWL ICE CREAM MAKERS: For you to use these ice cream makers you’ll need to freeze the bowl overnight.

Cuisinart ICE-30R Pure Indulgence Frozen Yogurt-Sorbet & Ice Cream Maker

The Cuisinart ICE-30R has a double-insulated freezer bowl, can hold up to 2 quarts of frozen deliciousness, and can be ready in as little as 25 minutes.

With its brushed nickel housing and its embossed logo this ice cream maker is as sexy as it is practical.

The price point for this machine is fantastic, but also its heavy duty motor and large ingredient spout makes this ice cream maker a home run in quality and value. Did we also mention that it has a three-year limited warranty? No wonder this is one of the best selling ice makers on Amazon today.

We have provided a link below so that you could take advantage of the lowest price available.  

Cuisinart ICE-21R Review

Another great ice cream maker that's available on Amazon  is the Cuisinart ICE-21R. This ice cream maker has several features that are worth noting.

First, the design of the mixing paddle allows your frozen dessert to be ready in 20 minutes.

Second, the large spout with its secure lock and transparency makes adding your favorite ingredients so simple and without the mess.

Its price is also really hard to beat. With all of these great features and with Its low price- no wonder thousands have already been sold on Amazon alone.

We’ve found you the best price, so click on the link below and head over to Amazon. 

The Hamilton Beach 68330N 4-Quart Automatic Ice Cream Maker

The Hamilton Beach 68330N 4-Quart Automatic Ice Cream Maker Review

Who doesn't like ice cream, frozen yogurt, custard, sherbet or gelato? What makes this even better is that with the Hamilton Beach ice cream maker, you can now make these awesome treats in your own kitchen and only in 20-40 minutes.

This ice cream maker produces 4 quarts of ice cream and with its fully automatic operation - you don't have to sweat it to get the sweet stuff.

All you have to do is add your ingredients, ice and rock salt and this ice maker will do all the rest for you.

The Hamilton Beach ice cream maker is an excellent ice cream maker for those family affairs - gather together as a family and create some ice cream memories. Build some superb ice cream sundaes together - and smile and laugh the night away.

Make Family Memories With Ice Cream

We recommend adding some candy, or fresh fruit. Wow! I mean the sky is the limit, and you get to taste your creations as you go.

We have found you the absolutely best price online, so click on the link below for more information. 

#3. TOP COMPRESSOR ICE CREAM MAKERS: These ice cream makers have a built-in compressor, so the unit itself does all the freezing for you without any extra effort.

Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker Electric Wood Bucket Ice Cream Maker

The Breville BC1600XL Smart Scoop, ice cream maker, is undoubtedly one of the best. Its self-refrigerating compressor means that it stays cold during the entire process and pre-freezing is not required. This ice maker also has 12 hardness settings for your frozen desserts so that you can quickly make sorbet, frozen yogurt, gelato and ice cream.

The Breville Smart Scoop has the ability to stay cool for three hours, and also features a child lock just in case your little one wants an early taste.

One big con with the Smart Scoop is that it does has a pretty steep price. You can head over to Amazon by clicking the link below and read more about it. 

If you love the idea of purchasing a self-refrigerating compressor ice cream maker, but you’re not crazy about the price. After you’ve read about the Smart Scoop you're excited about purchasing this type of machine, but there was no way you were going to pay that much for an ice cream maker. You may want to give the Whynter ICM-15LS a look. The Whynter ICE-15LS is pretty close to the Smart Scoop just cheaper. For more information you can head over to Amazon by clicking here

Cuisinart ICE-50BC Supreme Ice Cream Maker Review

This fully automatic ice maker has features that are truly boast worthy. It's a one and a half quart, frozen dessert maker that is sexy in its design.

It also has a commercial-style compressor, so you don't need to pre-freeze the bowl like many of the others. All you have to do set the timer and the ice cream maker will automatically shut off when your ice cream is ready.

It has a removable bowl for easy cleaning and features a very powerful motor. The handy recipe book that’s included is also a nice touch.


Consider How Long It Takes to Make Ice Cream 

Like most ice makIng appliances, you have to consider how long it takes to produce the end goal - ice.

Usually, it will take 20 or so minutes to make ice cream, and that's okay. You don't want to wait hours before you can enjoy all your hard work.

Before you purchase your ice cream maker, make sure that you check to see how long it takes to complete the ice cream making cycle. I mean, if you're going to wait for hours to get ice cream you might as well go to the store and buy it.

Consider How Much Ice Cream It Makes

The next important feature that you will need to consider is how much ice cream it produces in one sitting. Will it be enough for your whole family? You don't want anyone to be left out. Plus, can you have too much ice cream? I don't think so. 

Consider Its Power 

When it comes to ice cream makers, the more power the ice cream maker has, the better. It’s like Tim the Toolman Taylor always said on the Home Improvement tv show, “more power!”

I would also recommend that you invest in an electric ice cream maker and not a hand-churning one. You don't have time to sit there and make the ice cream - it's better to sit back and relax and know that soon you're going to have a wonderful frozen treat.

Do You Need An Ice Cream Maker?

I’m not sure if “need” is the right word to use. Prices are getting higher every single day. It's becoming more and more expensive to take the family out for ice cream.

Ice Cream makers are a great way to enjoy ice cream without the extra expense, and you can make your own creations. You can creative and have fun! 


[amazon table="666"]

Gather the family for an ice cream tonight and make your very own ice cream desserts.

It's also important to note that ice cream makers are also great for making slushies. We often will add fruit juice or even soda to our ice cream maker and make cool slushies on those hot summer days.

Ice Maker Geeks are ice enthusiasts that review ice-making appliances, research ice-related topics, and do our best to help you make an informed decision before you make a purchase. Over the years of running this website, we have learned a lot and we’re excited to share that knowledge with you. The article you just read is just a small sample of the work that we have been doing over the last several years.

Let us know what you’re thinking. Seriously!

Leave a reply

Ice Maker Geeks
Compare items
  • Total (0)


In this comprehensive buyers guide, youre going to learn the secrets of big ice maker manufacturers, and what you need to know before you buy any ice maker.

  • check
    I’m going to reveal to you everything I have learned about buying an ice maker from the years of operating this site
  • Get a comprehensive cleaning and maintenance guide
  • check
    Constantly Updated Information of prices, sales and discounts. 
  • check
    The best ice maker buyers guide on the world-wide-web