Scotsman Ice Maker Review

Scotsman ice machines have been on the market for a long time. They’re not the cheapest ice maker brand available, but they do have an exceptional reputation for being one of the best ice maker manufacturers around.

In this post, we’re going to determine if you should purchase a Scotsman ice maker for your home or business. We’ll give you all the numbers, facts and opinions of professionals and Scotsman ice maker owners, and you’ll be able to determine if owning a Scotsman is the best choice for you.

Let’s get started.

About Scotsman

Scotsman began the evolution of ice machines in the 1950s with its dedication to creating an ice maker that was both affordable and reliable.

Scotsman Ice Maker Review

Scotsman ice makers can be found in 100 countries around the world, and they boast that there are more than a million units that proudly carry the name of Scotsman.

What separates Scotsman from all the other ice makers? They understand the vital part ice plays in business and in life, whether you’re a hotel, restaurant, bar, supermarket, fast-food outlet, hospital, laboratory, or a food processing facility, Scotsman design their units with you and your business in mind.

Their focus for every ice machine is quality, efficiency, food safety, and performance. Scotsman ice makers offer the most variety of ice than any other manufacturer, as well as their famous nugget ice, which is soft chewable ice and is perfect for healthcare facilities.

The bottom line, Scotsman has been making ice makers longer than I have been alive, they know their stuff.

back to menu ↑

Are Scotsman Ice Machines Good?

Scotsman ice makers are very good, in fact, they are arguably the best on the market. There isn’t a business, office or home that wouldn’t benefit from having a Scotsman ice maker around.

There are a few features that separate the Scotsman brand from all the other ice makers on the market.

Check these out.

Quality

Scotsman produces great quality ice. They were the innovators behind the nugget ice, soft chewable ice, and continued developing new ways ice machines operate and how we use ice.

Scotsman ice machines are designed to produce quality ice. With proper maintenance, your ice maker will continue to provide clean, refreshing ice for your customers and family for years to come.

Quiet Operation

This may seem like something that’s not a big deal, but it’s an integral part of how ice makers operate and how much they interfere with our lives. Loud ice makers can affect our sleep, disturb our customers, and are just annoying.

This is the reason why Scotsman has invested so much time and money in the design of their compressors. Low noise levels of their units is another reason why Scotsman ice makers are the best.

Simple Maintenance

The regular maintenance of any ice maker is what guarantees the unit will last and will produce pure ice. Scotsman designs its units to be cleaned with ease, a technology that regulates and alerts you of any issues, and a device that can be taken apart for a thorough clean.

Overall, Scotsman ice machines are at the top of ice production, maintenance and operation.

back to menu ↑

Types of Scotsman Ice Makers

Scotsman offer serval different types of ice makers, and not all of them will be right for your business or home. In this post, we’re going to break them all down and give you direction on which one you should purchase.

Below are the different types of ice, Scotsman ice makers produce.

Nugget Ice

Scotsman nugget ice makers

Nugget or sonic ice which is The Original Chewable Ice® was developed by Scotsman in 1981. When developed it changed how we would eat ice. Nugget ice is soft, chewable ice and is perfect for healthcare facilities such as hospitals, nursing homes and doctor offices because they are not a choking hazard like regular cubed ice.

Nugget ice is perfect for:

  • Soft Drinks
  • Frozen Coffee
  • Frozen Cocktails
  • Smoothies

There are three types of ice makers that produce nugget ice: dispensers, modular and undercounter units.

Scotsman has several small ice dispensers called the Meridian™ Series Ice and Water Dispenser. These ice and water dispensers are perfect for offices, nursing homes and doctor offices because they are small and compact. They produce between 260-500 pounds of ice each day.

The Prodigy Plus ice makers come in a tall, slim self-serve units and large modular units. These ice makers produce between 450-2100 pounds of ice each day.

Cubed Clear

Scotsman Cubed Ice

Cubed ice is perfect for a host of events and occasions. It’s perfect for any beverage, and would work well at a restaurant or any business that serves food.

Cubed Ice is perfect for:

  • Soft Drinks
  • Cocktails
  • Bagged Ice
  • Dispensed Ice

The Scotsman ice makers that produce cubed ice are called cubers and come in three main categories. There are the BIG CUBE, which serves perfectly square and large ice cubes (biggest cube – 1¼” x 1¼” x 1¼” dimensions), the Prodigy Plus which comes in a variety of sizes, and the Prodigy Plus Eclipse, which are large narrow self-serving ice stations that serve cubed ice. The largest is the Prodigy Plus Eclipse 1800 which produces almost 1800 pounds of ice each day.

For smaller units, Scotsman created the CU0 series of ice makers which produce between 65-350 pounds of ice.

Flaked Ice

Scotsman Flaked Ice

Flaked ice is perfect for businesses that pack and ship food. With flaked ice, it’s easy to pack around the product so that it keeps cold for a long time.

Flaked ice is perfect for:

  • Chilled Food in a Buffet
  • Seafood or Meat in a Display
  • Blended Beverages
  • Cups of Ice for Medical Use

Scotsman have several small flake ice makers that produce between 96-440 pounds of ice each day.

Their larger Prodigy Plus units will make 500-1400 pounds of ice. If you need a lot of flaked ice, then The Scotsman Flaker is the unit for you, producing a whopping 2400 pounds of flaked ice every day.

back to menu ↑

Machine Heads and Bins

Many of the ice makers you’re going to see on this list are ice maker heads which require you to purchase a separate storage bin.

Make sure when you purchase your machine head that you purchase the correct corresponding ice storage bin. Not all units fit together, so it’s important to confirm that your machine head and bin are a correct pair. At Appliances Connection, they give you the recommended storage bin for each machine head, so you’re never wondering if it’s the correct match.

Determine how much ice you’re going to need for your business. Below is a chart which will give you a rough idea of how much ice you’re going to need, then you can purchase the correct sized storage bin.

back to menu ↑

How Much Ice Do I Need?

Before you can decide which ice maker will work for you and your business, you need to determine how much ice you’re going to use each day.

Check out the best commercial ice makers for home and business here.

We provided a simple chart that gives you estimations on how much ice different businesses could potentially use each day.

Remember, these numbers are just estimations, and only you can know how much ice your business will require.

Business TypeAverage Ice Needs Per Day
Restaurant1.5 lbs. per customer
Cocktail Lounge3 lbs. per customer
Hotel5 lbs. per guest room
Self-serve3 lbs. per person
Quick-service Restaurant5 oz. per 7- to 10-oz. cup 
8 oz. per 12- to 16-oz. cup 
12 oz. per 18- to 24-oz. cup
Salad Bar/Seafood Display35 lbs. per cubic foot
back to menu ↑

Air-Cooled, Water-Cooled and Remote

Often times when purchasing a new ice maker, you’ll see three styles of condensers – air-cooled, water-cooled and remote condenser. The condenser is a crital part of your ice maker, and something that you should understand.

When it comes to the condenser, you’ll need to choose an ice maker that properly fits your venue.

Air-Cooled Condensers

The most popular type of ice maker are air-cooled units. These ice makers use fresh air to move across the condensers to cool the equipment.

These units are the simplest to install because everything is neatly tucked inside the ice maker. There is no need of any additional installation.

The only CON with an air-cooled ice maker is that it’s more bulkier than other units. This is because the ice maker is designed with additional clearance to allow the air to pass over the condensers.

We nearly always recommend air-cooled units for more operations, but there are times when a remote condenser is best. If you need to install an ice maker with an ambient air temperature that regularly exceed 80 degrees, then I suggest a remote condenser for your business.

Higher ambient air temperatures will mean your ice maker will struggle with producing enough ice, and the constant demand can cause your ice maker to fail.

Water-Cooled Condensers

Water-cooled ice makers also have condensers contained inside the unit, but they require a constant flow of cold water to run pass over the condenser to remove the heat. This means that your ice maker will need a second source of water in order for it to function correctly. This is often not feasible for most businesses.

The PRO of a water-cooled ice maker is that it’s far more efficient than other types of units, but, again, normally very hard to make it work.

The best scenario for water-cooled ice machines is when a business has a water-circulating chiller system to tie their ice machine into.

Remote Condensers

Instead of the condenser self-contained within the ice maker, remote condensers are housed in a different location, normally outside.

Remote condensers are good because it means you don’t have to deal with the excess noise and heat, but remote condensers are hard to install and cost a lot more money than self-contained condensers.

back to menu ↑

Which Scotsman Ice Maker Should I Purchase

With so many different units available for you to purchase, it’s hard to determine which one will be best for your home, business, factory, or healthcare facility.

We’re going to break down each unit and determine which unit you should purchase.

We have added links to each unit which will give you the best price available.

Let’s find you a great Scotsman ice maker.

The Best Scotsman Ice Maker for a Hotel or Motel

If you are an owner of a hotel or motel and you’re in need of an ice maker that can keep up with the demand of your customers, then I suggest you choose the Scotsman Prodigy Plus series.

These ice makers come in two parts: the ice machine head and a separate storage bin.

Notice the best ice maker for a hotel or motel below:

Scotsman C0530MA1 100 Rooms or less

This Scotsman ice maker is a great unit for a small sized restaurant, bakery or cafe.
This ice maker produces 525 pounds of ice each day.

Scotsman C0830SA32 181 rooms or less

This Scotsman ice maker is great for larger restaurants for businesses that use a lot of ice each day.
This ice maker produces 905 pounds of ice each day

Scotsman C1030MA32 200 rooms or less

This Scotsman ice maker is perfect for small-medium hotels and large restaurants.
This ice maker produces 1077 pounds of ice each day

Scotsman C2148MR3 best CHOICE FOR LARGE HOTELs

This ice maker is perfect for larger hotels that use an extreme amount of ice each day. For large hotels or businesses that need a lot of ice, it’s recommended that you purchase the Scotsman BH1600SSA storage bin.
This ice maker produces 1965 pounds of ice

Scotsman HD30W1 ice storage & water

The HD30W-1 30" IceValet Hotel Ice and Water Dispenser with 180 lbs. capacity, push chute and easy-access bin in stainless steel. This requires an ice machine head.
Stores 180 pounds of ice each day with a water dispenser
10

Scotsman HD30B1 ice storage only

The HD30W-1 30" IceValet Hotel Ice Dispenser with 180 lbs. capacity, push chute and easy-access bin in stainless steel. This requires an ice machine head.
Stores 180 pounds of ice each day

The Scotsman Prodigy Plus series come with four important features that I want to hit on in this article.

First, indicator lights that alert you to important actions. When the ice maker needs attention (like when it’s time to descale, sanitize and more), the ice maker will signal your staff to take action.

Second, Watersense technology helps reduce scale buildup so that you’re not spending all your time cleaning this ice maker.

Third, Vari-Smart which gives you the control of scheduling your ice output for up to seven days. This way your ice is always clean and tasting great.

Lastly, this ice maker is fully controlled by some pretty advanced technology, so that you get the diagnosis of operating issues. When issues begin to show their ugly face, this ice maker will notify you, and help you solve the problem.

The Best Scotsman Ice Maker for Healthcare, Lunchrooms, and Offices

I recommend healthcare facilities use nugget ice for their patients and customers. Nugget ice is easier to chew and is less of a choking hazard than other types of ice.

For nursing homes and retirement residences, we recommend that you purchase the Scotsman Meridian Series.

These ice makers are perfect because they sit on the countertop and are compact and out of the way. These units are constructed with heavy-duty stainless steel, air-cooled and dispenses water as well as ice.

They come with two different types of cooling options: air cooled and water cooled. These ice maker can either be placed on a countertop or you can purchase a unit that can be mounted on the wall.

Your residents will be able to serve themselves, whenever they are in need of a cold, refreshing glass of water. It’s also perfect for office lunchrooms because these units don’t take up a lot of room.

For larger quantities of ice, we recommend the NME series. These ice makers produce an extraordinary amount of ice each day (Over 2100 pounds of nugget ice).

Scotsman HID540A1 best CHOICE FOR healthcare

This ice maker is perfect for health facilities, nursing homes and retirement homes.
This ice maker produces 500 pounds of ice each day and gives you 40 pounds of storage

Scotsman HID312A1

This compact ice maker produces 260 pounds of ice each day, it’s perfect for your office lunchroom.
This ice maker produces 260 pounds of ice and gives you 12 pounds of storage

Scotsman HID525A1

This ice maker is great for small doctor’s offices, and large office lunchrooms.
This ice maker produces 500 pounds of ice each day and gives you 25 pounds of storage

Scotsman N0622W1

This Scotsman ice maker with the Scotsman ID200B1 counter top ice dispenser with 200 pounds storage capacity is a perfect partnership for a nursing home or retirement residence.
This ice maker produces 715 pounds of ice

Scotsman NME1854RS32

This Scotsman nugget ice maker paired with the Scotsman B948S ice storage bin, is perfect for hospitals, doctors offices, nursing homes or any business looking for a lot of soft, chewable nugget ice.
Produces 2185 pounds of nugget ice

Scotsman F1522A32 BEST FOR FLAKE ICE

Prodigy Plus is a air-cooled flake ice machine with 1612 pounds of daily capacity, AutoAlert indicator lights, QR code access and stainless steel design. You’ll need to purchase a storage bin, great for cups of ice for medical reasons.
Produces 1612 pounds of flake ice each day.

The Best Scotsman Ice Makers for Bars and Restaurants

Scotsman ice makers are great units for restaurants and bars. We recommend cubed ice for cocktails, soft drinks, blended frozen drinks, bagged ice and dispensed ice because of its slow-melting properties.

You could also use half-diced ice or small ice cubes for bars and restaurants. Half-diced or small ice cubes offer a high ice-to-water ratio, which means that you get more ice into your beverage which chills it quicker and longer.

Some of the Scotsman ice makers below will need a storage bin accessory added to your order. These storage bins come in a host of sizes and features. Depending on how many customers you have daily, you will need to purchase a bin that holds enough ice to meet the demand.

Scotsman CU3030SA1 BEST choice FOR SMALL QUANTITIES

The CU3030SW-1 Prodigy air cooled undercounter, small cube ice machine with 347 pounds of daily capacity, 110 pounds of storage capacity, AutoAlert control panel and WaterSense purge control in stainless steel.
Produces 347 pounds of small ice cubes each day. Storage Bin is Included (110 Pounds).

Scotsman C0530MR1

C0530MR-1 30" Prodigy Plus Remote Condenser that produces medium cubed ice with 500 pounds of daily capacity, AutoAlert indicator lights, WaterSense purge control and Harvest Assist in a beautiful looking stainless steel.
Produces 500 pounds of medium cubed ice each day

Scotsman C2148SR32

C248SR-32 48" Prodigy Plus Remote Condenser Small Cube Ice Machine with 1965 pounds daily capacity, autoalert indicator lights, WaterSense purge control and harvest assist in stainless steel.
Produces 1965 pounds of small ice cubes

Scotsman C2648MR3

The Scotsman C2648MR-3 48" Prodigy Plus Remote Condenser which serves medium cubed ice and produces 2630 pounds of ice daily, AutoAlert indicator lights, WaterSense purge control and Harvest Assist in beautiful stainless steel.
Produces 2630 of medium ice cubes

Scotsman ID250B1 BEST ice Dispenser

D250B-1 30” is a great counter top ice dispenser with 250 pounds of storage capacity and insulated heavy-duty drip tray in amazing stainless steel.
Stores 250 pounds of ice at one time

The Best Scotsman Ice Maker for Cafés, Coffee Shops and Cafeterias

Cafés and coffee shops also need dependable ice makers for their everyday operations. Cafés and coffee shops are known for creating fantastic iced coffee, smoothies, and other taste-satisfying beverages.

Cafeterias use ice for several purposes such as keeping a salad bar cooled, dispensers for soft drinks and creating speciality drinks such as iced coffee.

We recommend that a café, coffee shop and cafeteria use cubed or small cubed ice. Cubed ice melts slower, cools beverages faster and is versatile.

Because Cafés, coffee shops and cafeterias are normally smaller than restaurants, we recommend a smaller unit that produces around 100-500 pounds of ice each day.

We also suggest that you purchase an undercounter unit so that it’s tucked away neatly and easily accessible.

We recommend the Scotsman Prodigy Series.

Scotsman CU3030SA1 best choice for a cafe, coffee shop or cafeteria

CU3030SA-1 30" Prodigy Air Cooled Undercounter which produces small cubed ice. This unit will produce 313 pounds of ice daily, and 110 pounds of storage capacity. It features AutoAlert control panel and WaterSense purge control in stainless steel – 115 volts.
Produces 313 pounds of ice small cubed ice daily and stores 110 pounds

Scotsman CU1526SA1

Scotsman CU1526SA1 Prodigy Air Cooled Undercounter which produces small cubed ice. This unit will produce 180 pounds of ice daily, and 80 pounds of storage capacity. It features AutoAlert control panel and WaterSense purge control in stainless steel – 115 volts.
Produces 180 pounds of ice each day and stores 80 pounds of ice at one time

The Best Scotsman Ice Maker for Outside Use

Not only are Scotsman ice makers trusted for businesses all over the USA, but they are also a well-used brand for homes, especially using outside by a pool or on a patio.

Scotsman sells a wide-variety of great ice makers for residential use, and more specifically for your outside kitchen.

These ice makers have a beautiful stainless steel construction, they are front venting (which means you can enclose them in your cabinets), are ETL listed, and produce either soft-chewable nugget ice, or gourmet ice.

Gourmet ice is uniquely-shaped, crystal-clear, slow-melting, taste-free, odorless ice. Gourmet ice won’t dilute the flavor of your beverage.

Scotsman SCN60PA1SS best choice FOR OUTSIDE use

15 Inch outdoor freestanding and built-in ice maker with 80 pounds daily ice production, 26 pounds of ice storage, nugget ice, ETL listed, and is designed and built in stainless steel. (Pump drain)
Produces 80 pounds of nugget ice each day.

Scotsman SCN60GA1SS

15 Inch outdoor freestanding and built-in ice maker with 80 pounds daily ice production, 26 pounds of ice storage, nugget ice, ETL listed, and is designed and built in stainless steel. (Gravity drain)
Produces 80 pounds of nugget ice each day.

Scotsman DCE33A1SSD

15 Inch undercounter ice maker with 30 pounds of daily ice production, 26 pounds of ice storage, gourmet ice, auto shut-off, UL listed, and in panel ready. (Pump drain)
Produces 30 pounds of gourmet ice.

Best Scotsman Ice Maker for a Grocery Store

The best choice for a grocery store ice maker is one that produces cubed ice or flake ice. Flake ice is great for displaying seafood, or for packing food for shipment.

The best ice maker for a grocery store will probably produce around 1000-2000 pounds of ice each day. For this type of ice quantity, you’re going to need to purchase a machine head, and the correct sized storage bin.

Below are our recommendations for the best ice maker for a grocery store.

Scotsman F1522A32 best for flake ice

F1522A-32 23" Prodigy Plus Air Cooled Flake Ice Machine with 1612 lbs. Daily Capacity, AutoAlert Indicator Lights, QR Code Access in Stainless Steel
Produces 1612 pounds of flake ice each day

Scotsman F1222A3

F1222A-3 23" Prodigy Plus Air Cooled Flake Ice Machine with 1100 lbs. Daily Capacity, AutoAlert Indicator Lights, QR Code Access in Stainless Steel
Produces 1100 pounds of flake ice each day

Scotsman C2648MR3 best for cubed ice

C2648MR-3 48" Prodigy Plus Remote Condenser Medium Cube Ice Machine with 2630 lbs. Daily Capacity, AutoAlert Indicator Lights, WaterSense Purge Control and Harvest Assist in Stainless Steel
Produces 2630 pounds of medium cubed ice

Best Scotsman Ice Maker for Your Home Bar, Basement, Garage or Kitchen

I want to conclude this post with the best Scotsman ice makers for your home. If you are looking for an ice maker for a newly renovated kitchen, basement, home bar, or garage, then you’re in the right place.

Scotsman offer great ice makers for businesses (there is no doubt about it), but they should not be excluded from residential use as well.

Below are the best Scotsman ice makers for residential use.

Scotsman SCN60PA1SU best choice FOR KITCHENs

15 Inch Freestanding and Built-In Ice Maker with 80 lbs. Daily Ice Production, 26 lbs. Ice Storage, Nugget Ice, ETL Listed, in Panel Ready
Produces 80 pounds of nugget ice each day

Scotsman UN324A1 best choice FOR GARAGEs

UN324A-1 24" Essential Ice Air Cooled Undercounter Nugget Ice Machine with 340 lbs. Daily Production Capacity, 80 lbs. Storage Capacity and External Air Filter in Black and Grey
Produces 340 pounds of nugget ice each day

Scotsman CU0415MA6 best choice FOR BASEMENTs

CU0415MA-6 15" Essential Ice Air Cooled Undercounter Medium Cube Ice Machine with 58 lbs. Daily Capacity, Slide-Up Door, and 36 lbs. Storage Capacity in Grey
Produces 58 pounds of cubed ice each day

Scotsman CU50PA1A best choice FOR HOME BARs

CU50PA-1A 15" Air Cooled Commercial Under Counter Cube Ice Machine with 26 lb Ice Storage Capacity, 65 lb Daily Ice Production, Water Quality Detector and UL Approved for Outdoor Use, in Stainless Steel
Produces 65 pounds of cubed ice each day
back to menu ↑

Conclusion

Scotsman ice makers are reliable units and will be perfect for your home or business.

We have listed the best units above, and hope that this article guides you to make an informed decision. Click on the link provided and get more information, and the best prices we could find online.

If you have any questions or comments please add them below.

Scotsman ice makers are at the top, and you won’t be disappointed making the investment for your business or home.

Ice Maker Geeks are ice enthusiasts that review ice-making appliances, research ice-related topics, and do their best to help you make an informed decision before you make a purchase. Over the years of running this website, they have learned a lot and are excited to share that knowledge with you. The article you just read is just a small sample of the work that they have been doing over the last several years.

Let us know what you’re thinking. Seriously!

      Leave a reply